patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

'Save the Deer' Group Forms to Stop Bow Hunting

Website has petition, signs available.

 

You’ve seen the signs popping up around town. The message is hard to miss: “NO HUNTING,” the black letters say against a backdrop of hunter orange.

Avon Lake resident Tim Slater has city leaders and the Ohio Department of Natural Resources in his crosshairs and is sending out a message that hunting in Avon Lake is not wanted or needed.

Click here to read all Avon Lake articles about culling, deer overpopulation and accidents.

He, along with a half a dozen other Avon Lake residents have formed a group that is posting the orange and black signs throughout the city and spreading their message through a new website, www.avonlakedeer.com.

When asked why the group formed, Slater said, “We started it to stop--stop this hunting proposal.”

Slater does not believe the city has a deer overpopulation problem and questions the method used by the city with the Ohio Department of Natural Resources' (ODNR) backing to count them. Slater believes that method, the “deer spotlight” program, does not provide an accurate count. 

“You would get laughed at in most places for using that,” Slater said. “The data is from ODNR and their motive always is selling more hunting licenses and deer hunting equipment.

“They are always going to inflate the number.”

Slater said the question of overpopulation is just one issue.

“So you introduce a hunting program of big game animals in the name of safety with high-powered weapons?” he asked. “Hunting is extremely, extremely dangerous. The people who understand that don’t want any part of hunting in our community.”

Slater believes that putting lighted flashing warning lights in areas where there are a high number of deer, such as on Walker Road, where there were 12 deer vs. vehicle accidents last year, makes more sense than hunting.

“There are six places in town there should be signs,” Slater said. “This is a common-sense approach.”

His website supports that.

“We are surprised that warnings and traffic controls are almost non-existent along these roads,” avonlakedeer.com states.  “Other communities have had success with highly visible, lighted deer crossing signs to warn motorists in similar situations.” 

Slater added that a deer injured—not killed—by an arrow can be dangerous.

“When you hit a deer with an arrow, it runs, anywhere it can,” he said. “They can run for a mile,  five miles…They can live for quite awhile, while suffering.”

The city of Solon just completed its deer culling program, removing 300 deer from the town since February after hiring ODNR sharpshooters.

As for the “no feeding the deer” ordinance, which will be discussed tonight at a joint Safety Committee/Environmental Committee meeting, Slater said the proposed law makes no sense, nor does hunting to prevent vegetation from being ruined.

“Who in their right mind is going to kill deer because they are eating the flowers?” Slater asked. “I don’t know why we should stop feeding the deer. There’s not a stitch of information to say that stop feeding the deer is going to help.”

He said planting deer-resistant plants and flowers or using deer repellant could solve the problem.

The feedback to his site, which has an online petition with more than 100 signatures, has been positive he said.

“It’s 10 to 1 against deer hunting,” Slater said. “Once people learned the facts they are shocked,” Slater said. “Who is going to move into city where they have deer hunting? No one wants a house where there’s deer hunting four months a year. Housing values will plummet.”

“I’ve been getting comments from both sides,” Zilka said, adding he would wait until after council began formal debates to further comment. He said he's seen the signs around town.

"The ordinance does not allow hunting in neighborhoods," he said.

 

Related Topics: Avon Lake Deer Overpopulation, bow hunting, and save the deer

David

7:53 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

So - what is the alternative? For those who believe there is an over-population problem a solution is needed. What is the alternative? I've never lived in a town in my life - and I've lived in four states, where it is common to walk out one's front door in the morning and have deer standing in the front yard...not while living in a town. Do we trap and relocate? Do we sterilize? I do believe we have an over-population - and every time I drive south from Walker on Lear I get nervous - it is commonplace to have deer dart across the road at dusk through that stretch.

Reply

Kristi

8:47 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Just because someone "thinks" there is an overpopulation problem, doesn't mean there is and doesn't mean something has to be done. Also, so what if you're nervous while driving. Just drive slower and be careful. My gosh. Are you seriously suggesting that killing deer is the solution to your being a little nervous? Personally, I see deer near my backyard all the time (i enjoy it), they eat my flowers every spring, I have been in a very minor car accident with a deer, and I do not believe we have a problem and I do not believe they need to be killed.

Reply

Rich

8:55 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Just to clarify; Councilwoman Fenderbosch did the count for ODNR and she and her husband have been bow hunting advocates for years.She's hardly an objective or scientific population analyst.

Reply

Cheryl Lister

9:12 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

We do indeed have an overpopulation problem with deer. Last spring at dusk, there were 9 deer in my side yard on their hind legs eating the buds on the maple trees. I'm not sure I favor bow hunting, but I do agree that residents should not feed the deer. The deer should be finding their own food sources and feeding them doesn't force that.

Reply

Aimee Miller

9:14 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Walking back in the woods off of Electric you can see more deer than you would think possible for such a small patch of woods. I saw about 30 deer back there a couple of weeks ago. My dog goes crazy almost every morning because there are deer eating my neighbors landscaping and during the summer their gardens. I had a huge buck in my neighbor's backyard last winter, it bent my chain link fence trying to escape. This is just in my little neighborhood off of Electric. So I know there is a real problem with deer over population. So I support the bow hunting...but if someone can come up with a viable alternative I will support that over the hunting. I just don't want to hear all the naysayers putting the idea down without some sort of alternative.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Lori E. Switaj

9:14 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

There is an article on the Solon Patch today that they just completed their deer culling program through ODNR, "removing" 300 deer. Check out the comments on that site----> http://patch.com/A-rWyf

Reply

Carol Lawler

9:28 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

A sign in my yard would say "YES, HUNT HERE, PLEASE!". My yard and the wooded area behind us are stripped bare. 19 deer in my yard and that is not overpopulation? This winter they were leaner that I have ever seen them....they have depleted their food sources because there are too many of them. Something needs to be done.

Reply

Angela k

10:02 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

The deer have a human problem in Avon Lake! We've taken their natural habitat away and they're left to try to evolve by changing their food sources to our flowers,fruits, vegetables and garbage. Since they do not have shrubs and forests to roam any longer, they roam our yards and streets. They are starving because of the limited and inferior food supply and dying unnatural deaths due to car accidents. We need to find a humane way to relocate many of them for their health and safety.

Reply
Comment_arrow

june jones

2:42 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Not really....there were no deer or nearly no deer in Ohio around 1930, so....it's actually a repopulation problem. There are now no natural predators present to maintain the population within the biological carrying capacity of the area.

Laurie

10:16 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Has anyone walked thru Save the Woods area and seen the deer "exclosure" fence? There you can see what should be on the forest floor. But the whole area is stripped bare because of the deer - and you don't think we have a problem? Who has to be killed or almost killed in an accident for these boneheads to realize there is a HUGE problem? It's not just about eating our flowers - it's about the health of the herd. Those deer are sick. They are having 2 fawns per year instead of one. Our city is growing and their habitat is being destroyed. The real suffering is watching them starve to death. That is cruel!

Reply

Jason Baird

10:17 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

You know what... I went outside the other day (oakwood drive in the 45's) and there was a bunch of deer **** on my front lawn. So not cool and so not what you expect in a neighborhood. Kill them, chase them, toss them in the lake and hope the swim to canada. Just get rid of them!

End rant.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Andrea S

10:54 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

We couldn't figure out why the dogs were going more nuts than usual last Sunday...until we looked out on our front lawn and saw the deer they were barking at. I don't think they've ever seen one before that....must have thought it was an enormously big dog lol.

chris

10:31 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Avon Lake has become a country club for the deer. There are just to many is this little town. All of the people that are against it have no clue to what is happening. I am sure all of you if not most of you have seen the piebald deer by the intersection of Moore rd and Walker. Why do you think that this deer is white? Natural selection? Ha!! Thinning the herd would not only help this great community but feed the thousands of homeless and less fortunate in the greater Cleveland area. Something needs to be done to help the the deer live healthy lives. Culling the herd isn't going to stop them from being in your backyard for you to enjoy. It's simply going to help keep this town safe when driving and keep the herd healthy.

Reply

Andrea S

10:52 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

The deer population will naturally regulate itself given enough time (and if people don't feed them). The Avon Lake speed limits are pretty low. If you are an alert driver (not on a cell phone) and not speeding your chances of hitting a deer decrease, or you hit them at such as low speed as to not do damage to your car. The deer are nearly always in the same four or five places, just expect you're going to see them around twilight, slow down and keep an eye out. I see them all the time and have never hit one. My husband hit one when he was going mayb 20mph and it just bounced off his car and kept walking. The city needs to focus it's time on bringing business to Avon Lake, planning for the fall in revenue after the GenOn plant closes, and working to basically make our town economically sound for the future. Forget the deer.

Reply

Nick B. Fernando

1:30 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

I don't feel safe for one minute in this town with all the deer running around! The other day the deer in my yard were looking at my children! If we cull the herd, they will repopulate. We need to eradicate every single one of the deer. We must destroy the remaining woods in the city so the deer have nowhere to hide once and for all! It might sound extreme now you'll all thank me when the community is finally safe!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Steve83

7:40 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Yes the deer will look at your children as they are either curious or are seeing if your children are a threat. That does not mean they are going to charge or attack. If you get too close - they will run away. The only exception is mating season - bucks will be territorial and not run away so readily. BTW - I have up to 15 deer in my yard at a time (I do NOT feed them) and have gotten fairly close with no threatening behavior - then they run away. I do advocate a sterilization program though to control the population.

Comment_arrow

Jan Y.

8:38 pm on Wednesday, May 9, 2012

oh yeah, the answer is to destroy the remaining few trees this city has, and while we're at it, why don't we just send the deer into extinction! This is so ridiculous, I'm not sure whether to take you seriously! I don't feel safe with you running around, Mr. Fernando!

Jen G

5:52 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

You have got to be kidding me!!! You are scared of a deer because he looks at you???? You are upset because they eat flowers??? It is a sad society that we live in where flowers are valued over a living animal! Sick! I am sickened by the lack of compassion! I welcome and enjoy seeing the deer in my yard. What a deprived group of people who would enjoy seeing a deer, or any animal drown. Get over it! Move to Cleveland where it's all blacktop if you are so scared/annoyed by the wildlife! I have lived here my entire life and have seen this city grow to a ridiculous size. Maybe the builders and city planners should have planned a little better.
People texting while driving cause accidents too....are we to put an arrow through their heads too??? Slow down and pay attention!!!!!! This is not an acceptable solution nor an effective one. Our city is not unsafe because of the deer but more from the heartless, cowards that live in this city!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Patricia Vinch

9:53 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

Gee Jen, I would be happy to move to Cleveland. Want to buy a condo with a bare yard!!!

Jen G

6:17 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

The bunnies eat flowers too...let's shoot them too! Come on...I am shocked at some of the responses on here. If you are worried about your kids when the deer look at them, imagine how you will feel when a deer with an arrow stuck in it comes charging into your yard! The deer are harmless and more scared of you than you of them. When the injured deer come flying out into traffic after being struck with an arrow, tell me how safe you will be. Based on the mentality of some of the hunters I have heard talk, I don't feel real safe with them running around with bows and arrows! Go live down south and enjoy hunting all you want.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Steve83

7:36 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

I have never had a deer go after me in my yard - when there is up to 15 at a time - most of the time if you get too close, they run away. I have had a buck during mating season scare me though. I walked out of my garage and around the corner of the house, and there it was. Not only scared me because I was not expecting it - but it started snorting at me. But it was mating season. While I am not happy they are eating my landscaping - I have found a couple of spray deterrents that are very effective. However, I do not like when the bucks mark there territory and strip the bark off of my trees - that is not a food problem.
As far as car/deer accidents. I have to drive at times at 2:00 in the morning. I go slow and use my brights driving down Jaycox - but I still have had them run out of the wooded areas near Brittania. Unless you drive 5 mph - it is hard to avoid them - and no - I do not text or sleep while I drive through that area. The comment that it is driver inattention or speed causing deer/car accidents is not always true (although some are).
I am not necessarily in favor of hunting - but I do think a sterilization program is in order to control the population level.

Comment_arrow

Patch reader

9:44 am on Sunday, April 1, 2012

I agree with Steve: "I am not necessarily in favor of hunting - but I do think a sterilization program is in order to control the population level."

I'm not necessarily in favor of hunting either but think there is a better solution. Do the same thing with the deer that others do with feral cats. Start a trap/neuter/release program.

Have the city start a sterilization program. Give permits to approved residents who have 3 or more acres, and allow them to put out feed and salt blocks that contain birth control.

Have a sharp shooter tranq and relocate some of the excess deer to S. Ohio.

Jen G

10:37 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012

I have no problem with other methods to control the deer population...and I think the builders should foot the cost! I do have a problem with senseless and cruel killing.

Reply

The Dream Team

7:20 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012

I can not believe that anyone can say there is not a problem with the deer over population. They must not get around Avon Lake. I was in conversation with some residents last night. We were trying to come up another city anywhere, which is like this. On the way home last night, we sa deer after deer the whole way home. It is a problem everywhere around Avon Lake, not just Walker or Jaycox. Every main road is a problem. And, for residents like me that likes to plant veggies or like nice plantings, forget it!!! I even think the building department needs to change the fence permits, to allow 6-8 ft whatever is need to keep them out of our yards. If it was a human pulling our plants out or cutting them down over and over, what would be done? I do not believe that bow hunting is the way, but something needs to be done. It is nothing to take a walk and see upto and more than 30 deer. I know there is a neighbor that feeds then and have the sugar block right in their back yard. I did notice this year, the deer are very big and healthy, because of the little to no winter, I’m sure. Something needs to be done.

Reply

Jen G

11:31 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012

I don't think anyone can argue that there are a lot of deer in Avon Lake. The question is, do we kill them?? I have lived in almost every corner of the city over the course of my life. I have children that I drive all over town constantly. The only time I see numerous deer is when we walk down the path across from Armour Rd. One of the reasons we walk down there, is to see the deer!
I do not believe that the only solution is to kill them. It is inhumane and unnecessary, not to mention dangerous and expensive.

Reply

Cheryl Lister

9:43 am on Friday, March 30, 2012

Many of the comments I'm reading about the deer problem ,or lack thereof, are obviously from residents who DON'T have deer in their yards! Is it more humane to thin the herd of allow the deer to starve to death?

Reply

Amy S

9:11 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012

After we solve this issue, I propose we move on to other woodland creatures. We can all agree there is an overpopulation of squirrels and birds in this town. They, too, can cause accidents and property damage. I even saw one looking at my children in a menacing way. Maybe BB guns? Darts?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jan Y.

8:50 pm on Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Ha, ha, good one Amy S! Yeah, just kill em all....violence is always the answer!
I can't believe how cruel and uncaring so many of these residents seem. I'm in complete agreement with any type of sterilization program that may be available...why didn't we investigate this a few years ago before it came to this? I've always enjoyed the peacefulness of riding through the woods - feeling like we can co-habitate with the deer, is very comforting, and I certainly never felt threatened by them. I hope the Avon Lake woods don't turn into a bloody killing zone!

Donna Dorn

1:20 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012

I am a 911 operator for the county. ALL of Lorain County. I can and do work all three shifts and I have worked here for almost 11 yrs. During the spring and fall, (andl many other times...sometimes there is no rhyme nor reason) I take many calls of deer getting hit, sometimes 3 or 4. That is just me. Multiply that times 3 more operators.Many times, due to budget cuts, which I am sure you all have read about, there are not alot of officers on the road, or they are tied up (yes, even in Avon Lake). Often, the police departments will ask the callers if the car is driveable and to report it to their insurance company. A human in trouble is going to get assistance from 911 over an injured deer EVERY time. It happens all the time.That deer may still be suffering or wounded JUST LIKE the ones you are so blatantly posting pictures of with arrows thru their bodies, and officers cannot go out to put them out of their misery. It just happens. It isn't anyones fault. But they suffer none the less. Is that fair??Once, I took a call of a deer who was hit on a bridge. Another car hit it as it was flopping. The poor caller watched in horror waiting for the police to come to finish it off and the deer continued to flail and went over the bridge into the river and most likely drowned.

Reply

Donna Dorn

1:21 am on Tuesday, April 3, 2012

(cont'd) , I would imagine. He watched it float away. I also took the call in Sheffield Village where 9 deer panicked and JUMPED to their deaths over the bridge on 254/ Gulf. Some were pregnant. That is real world people. People get hurt and killed from collisions. I myself, hit a deer on my way into work last year on Lear road. We cannot put an animals life above a humans, ever.I have taken calls of deer rolling up on windshields and nearly killing people. Those deer still lead a better life than any meat entree you have ever had before you at supper time, I guarantee it. Unless you are all vegetarians of course.
They are pretty. They are displaced. All hunters are not monsters and they do aim to kill humanely and efficiently.

Reply

Steve83

6:40 pm on Tuesday, April 3, 2012

Not to stray too far but are those who are against the hunting of deer in Avon Lake all vegetarians? I am not one but it is hypocritical to ignore the suffering of animals in our food chain and only look at deer just because they are "cuter". Also, don't use the argument of cows and pigs are raised for our consumption and deer are not because that does not make a difference. Of course, this is assuming the hunted deer are used for meat which they usually are.

Reply

jim fuderer

7:05 pm on Monday, May 14, 2012

we have lived in avon lake many years and have enjoyed the wild life a great deal !!!!! the problem is too many stores and people who do not care except for the almighty dollar and themselves. its always the easy way out ....destroy whats ever in our way!!!! WRONG...what will our children have when they grow up????letsput our heads together and think of a better way besides killing !!!! i am sure our troops in this god foresaken war would give anything to see all the deer... that i know !!! you who think other wise then trade places with them ..... this i know for sure

Reply

Howard E Williams

4:45 pm on Tuesday, June 5, 2012

There is another problem with the large over population of deer in AL. LYME Disease! Deer are confirmed carriers of the ticks that cause Lyme and studies have shown a correlation between the concentration of deer and disease rates in humans. (They can be accessed via the internet, just google Lyme disease in OH. We have lived in AL for over 40 years in the same location.
The first 25 or 30 years we hardly ever saw a deer, but now they are much too common. There have been as many as 11 in my yard at one time. I agree they are pretty to look at but the price we have to pay is too great in my opinion. In addition to the threat of disease they do a huge amount of damage to landscaping. During last years mild winter they ate the bark off a 30 year old Lilac putting its survival in doubt.

Howard

Reply

Leave a comment